5th annual what molly made
Pudding Cookie Contest
Join our creative baking contest by putting a holiday twist on our viral chocolate chip pudding cookies. Win a brand new Kitchen Aid mixer (or $400 gift card) AND a year long membership to the Guaca-Molly Club where you get meal plans, exclusive recipes, and my site completely ad free. Winners also get their cookie photographed and shared on WMM!
How to Participate
Make Your Cookie
Come up with your cookie idea, test it, and take pictures! It should be a holiday version of the pudding cookie, focusing on holiday flavors, ingredients, decorations, etc. They’re judged on 3 criteria. Here are some examples.
Submit Your Cookie
Submit your cookie using the form below with a picture of the cookie, the details you changed or added, and the name of your cookie.
Vote and Win!
The What Molly Made team will vote on the finalists and announce them on Instagram on Dec 16. Vote that day and the winner will be announced on Dec 17!
Submit Your Cookie!
How They’re Judged
- Creativity: The idea itself and if it’s Christmas- or holiday-focused. Think holiday flavors like gingerbread, peppermint, eggnog, or a special family tradition.
- Flavor: Does it taste good? While we can’t taste each cookie, we will base this rating on the flavor combination and how well they go together.
- Execution: Did it work and does it look good?! The pictures need to show that the cookie looks just as delicious as it sounds!
Examples from Previous Years
Last year’s winner: Reindeer tracks peanut butter pudding cookies.
More Fun Ideas From Previous Years:
- Elf Cookie with Maple Syrup, Candy Canes, Candy Corn, and M&Ms
- Green Grinch Pudding Cookies
- Peppermint Bark Pudding Cookies
- Eggnog pudding Cookies with frosting
- Grinch cookies
- Andes Mint Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwich Pudding Cookies
WMM cookies to give you inspo: peppermint bark cookie bars, frosted eggnog cookies, salted caramel stuffed cookies, chai cookies, Christmas crack cookies, polar bear paws, espresso martini cookies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, you can enter as many cookie ideas as you want! Create a separate entry form for each submission.
You win a brand new kitchen aid mixer or a gift card equivalent. You also get a membership to the Guaca-Molly Club for the year and your cookie is published on WMM!
Finalists will be announced on Instagram where the community will vote for the final winner! The final winner will be notified via email and announced on Instagram and an email to the WMM community.
Enter the contest and….
Win over $500 worth of prizes!
One winner gets a kitchen aid mixer (or gift card equivalent), a year long membership to the Gauca-Molly Club, and their cookie photographed and published on WMM!
